This guest post was written by Ashley Paling, a research technician at the Horticulture & Environmental Sciences Innovation Centre (HESIC) and part-time instructor at Niagara college.
Using biological controls to control aphids as part of an IPM strategy is a popular choice among growers (Jacob, 2023). Aphid parasitoids can, of course, be purchased weekly from suppliers. However this is an expensive option that leaves you at the mercy of waiting for weekly deliveries to control your greenhouse pests.
Enter the Banker Plant System: a relatively inexpensive option that provides you with a constant supply of beneficial biological controls. This article covers the ins and outs of how to use a banker plant system properly, and what you need to consider if you are going to set up a banker plant program in your greenhouse.
The Banker Plant System: What is it?
The Banker Plant System (BPS) is a self-contained system that uses a non-pest on a non-crop plant to rear beneficial insects to control your greenhouse pests (Jandricic and Frank, 2014; Skinner et al. 2016). While this system can be set up to control a variety of pests, one of the most common options is the Aphidius colemani BPS to control aphids (Skinner et al. 2016).
In the case of this system, the non-pest used is the Bird Cherry Oat Aphid (Rhopalosiphum padi), which is a pest to monocot species. These aphids feed on a monocot crop such as oats, wheat, rye, or barley. The beneficial insects A. colemani, are parasitic wasps, and use the R. padi to lay eggs and grow their own population (Huang et al. 2011; Koppert, 2016). The main reason this works is because the majority of commercial greenhouse bedding plants or vegetables are dicots, and the R. padi will not become a pest for your saleable crops (Frank Sullivan & Skinner, 2013; Skinner et al. 2016).
A. colemani works best at controlling green peach aphids (Myzus persicae) and cotton/melon aphids (Aphis gossypii) specifically, so identifying the usual aphid pest(s) in your greenhouse is important for this system’s success (Skinner et al. 2016). By continuously producing new monocot banker plants to rear your R. padi and A. colemani populations, you can have an long-term supply of beneficial biologicals available in your greenhouse.
Step by Step: Creating your own Banker Plant System
Materials you will need to create your own BPS: cages or hairnets, pots, planting media, grain seed (barley or wheat work best; Jandricic 2014), R. padi, A. colemani (a shipment of 500 for 3-4 weeks as you’re getting started), water, and fertilizer.
Week 1: Seed your first few banker plants, adding fertilizer and watering well. You will need to start with a minimum of two banker plants per acre of growing space and follow up with at least one new banker plant per acre each week (Jacob, 2023; Skinner et al. 2016).
Inoculate these newly seeded pots with your starting population of R. padi . These come on pre-infested grain plants, so just put the plant beside the seedlings in a cage or place several blades of infested grass on each pot and cover with a hairnet. Containing your R. padi is essential to keep any A. colemani in your greenhouse away from your plants until the R. padi population has built up enough to to be able to a) use it to re-infest more plants or b) properly support a parasitoid population.
Week 2: Seed another round of new banker plants as you did in week one (Figure 1). Take 3 – 5 blades with R. padi from your one-week-old plant (Figure 2) and place them directly on your newly seeded plants from this week, keeping them protected, as in week 1 (Skinner et al. 2016).
Week 3: Continue seeding and inoculating new plants as in weeks 1 and 2. Evaluate the population of your R. padi from the week 1 plants this week. If they are abundant (at least 10 R. padi per blade), release 100 A. colemani into each pot. Place them under the hair nets or in the cages (Figure 3) so they don’t fly away initially (Koppert, 2023). Continue watering and fertilizing plants as necessary.
Week 4: Continue seeding and inoculating new plants as in weeks 1 and 2. Take the banker plants you planted in week 1, which now also have A. colemani, and evaluate the A. colemani population. If you can see R. padi mummies with exit holes and A. colemani flying around, remove the net and place them around the greenhouse (Figure 4). If you only have a small population of mummified R. padi, hold off on releasing for one more week. Continue watering and fertilizing plants as necessary.
Weeks 5-6 and on: To keep the population of your A. colemani growing and predating on your pest aphids, continue seeding and inoculating new banker plants with R. padi then A. colemani for a total of 5 or 6 weeks (Jacob, 2023; Skinner et al. 2016). At this point, after having followed the above schedule, the A. colemani population should be well established in your greenhouse and should not need replenishing. The exception to this would be if something happens to make your A. colemani population crash (e.g. pesticide applications, hyperparasitoids). Ensure you are continuously providing the A. colemani population with fresh banker plants inoculated with R. padi each week.
The Pros and Cons of a Banker Plant System
Like all pest management strategies, there are both pros and cons for the A. colemani banker plant system. Knowing the challenges of the BPS can help you know what to expect and prepare you for troubleshooting issues before you start. However, the positives outweigh the negatives for this strategy, which has been widely accepted in many growing regions.
CONS:
- Requires consistent watering, fertilization, and monitoring the status of your banker plants. If watering is missed and your banker plants begin to suffer, so does your beneficial population.
- May have different water and nutrient needs than your crop, so think about how you’ll take care of them before you grow. Some growers place them on flood benches (Figure 5); others hang them up and hand-water, or put them on separate watering lines. Different potting mixes that hold water differently are also an option.
- Not appropriate for some monocot crops, like Easter Lilies or ornamental grasses, since the R. padi would be at risk of becoming a pest to your saleable crops (Skinner et al. 2016).
PROS:
- This is an inexpensive way to produce a large amount of A. colemani compared to purchasing new biologicals every week.
- Can be applied to a wide variety of commercially grown dicot crops.
- Help you monitor the health and activity of your parasitoid population (by looking for mummies on the bankers).
- Provides parasitoids that are “fresher” (Jandricic and Frank 2014) that can be more effective than wasps from commercial sources.
- Wasps are more recently hatched, meaning they have their whole life span (7 – 10 days [Jacob, 2023]) to parasitize aphids in your greenhouse.
6 Top Tips for Growers Trying this System!
Here are our top tips for running a successful Aphidius colemani banker plant system in your greenhouse:
- This system is preventative, not reactionary! You need to be able to get ahead of the pest pressure for it to work effectively. The best timing is to start your banker plant system 6 weeks before your earliest expected crop that regularly gets aphids will be planted in your greenhouse (Skinner et al. 2016).
- Be consistent with your watering! There is nothing more disappointing than seeing your pest populations rise because you had some wilted banker plants over the weekend.
- Remember that your banker plants need fertilizer too! Just as it is important to remember to water your banker plants, so too is it crucial to ensure they are receiving fertilizer when they need it. Hooking up your banker plants to a drip line that gets regularly fertigated is a good way to avoid forgetting them.
- Make sure your cages or hair nets are secured and free of small holes! Having a fully secured environment to keep your A. colemani from parasitizing the R. padi population before it has a chance to multiply is extremely important.
- The type of monocot crop you use for your banker plant does matter! Oats have been determined to be the least effective, providing you with lower R. padi populations and therefore less parasitoids. Wheat and barley provide the R. padi with the most nutrients, which lead to healthier A. colemani populations (Jandricic and Frank 2014).
- Do not remove the banker plants until they start to die, to get the most out of your banker plant program. They can last 8-10 weeks.
By following these steps and helpful tips, you should be able to have your own Banker Plant System up and running, providing your greenhouse with a constant supply of beneficials, in no time!
Acknowledgements:
This article was written under the supervision of Sebastian Jacob, Professor of the Niagara College Greenhouse Production Science course (W23), where students got hands-on experience developing banker plant systems. Small edits for clarity/accuracy were made by S. Jandricic.
References
Anatis Bioprotection. (2023). Aphid Banker Plants. Anatis Bioprotection Products. Retrieved on April 13th, 2023 from https://anatisbioprotection.com/en/biological-control-products/aphids-banker-plant-system/
Frank Sullivan, C. E., & Skinner, M. (2013). Plant-mediated IPM systems explained. University of Vermont Entomology Research Laboratory.
Huang, N., Enkegaard, A., Osborne, L., Ramakers, P., Messelink, G., Pijnakker, J., & Murphy, G. (2011). The banker plant method in biological control. Critical Reviews in Plant Science, 30: 259-278.
Jacob, S. (2023). Unit 1 – Banker Plants. Blackboard Presentation.
Jandricic, S., and Frank, S. (2014). Boosting bankers. Greenhouse Canada. Retrieved on April 6th, 2023 from https://www.greenhousecanada.com/boosting-bankers-4310/
Koppert Canada Ltd. (2016). Biological control of aphids – Aphidius colemani. YouTube Video Retrieved on April 6th, 2023 from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=StSO7LSzzAw
Koppert Canada Ltd. (2023). Aphipar. Retrieved on April 6th, 2023 from https://retail.koppert.ca/products/aphipar
Skinner, M., Frank Sullivan, C. E., & Valentin, R. (2016). Aphid banker plant system for greenhouse IPM, step by step. University of Vermont Entomology Research Laboratory.